Is It God or Just My Thoughts? Why Discernment Gets So Confusing
If you’ve already accepted that God speaks, this question hits differently.
You’re not wondering if God can guide you.
You’re wondering why, in real life, it still feels so hard to tell what’s Him and what’s just your own thinking.
That confusion doesn’t come from lack of faith.
It usually comes from too much internal and external noise layered on top of discernment.
Why Discernment Feels Clear One Day—and Impossible the Next
One of the most misunderstood aspects of hearing God is consistency.
People assume that once you “learn” how God speaks, clarity should be automatic. But discernment isn’t static. It’s affected by your emotional state, your environment, and what voices you’re allowing access to your decisions.
When life is calm, hearing God often feels simple.
When stakes are high, discernment feels fragile.
That’s not because God stopped speaking.
It’s because the signal is competing with interference.
The Three Most Common Sources of Interference
Over time, I’ve noticed three patterns that consistently blur discernment — even for spiritually mature people.
1. Overthinking Masquerading as Responsibility
Overthinking doesn’t feel sinful. It feels careful.
But when you replay conversations, imagine outcomes, and mentally rehearse decisions over and over again, you’re no longer listening — you’re managing anxiety.
Discernment requires presence.
Overthinking pulls you into hypothetical futures God hasn’t asked you to solve yet.
2. External Voices Carrying More Weight Than God’s
Wise counsel matters. But when everyone’s opinion gets equal airtime, discernment collapses into confusion.
I’ve watched people hear something clearly from God — only to immediately dilute it by asking five different people what they think. Not because they’re rebellious, but because they don’t trust themselves to recognize God’s voice without approval.
Discernment doesn’t mean isolation.
It means knowing which voice has final authority.
3. Emotional Stakes Raising the Volume
When a decision involves money, relationships, security, or reputation, emotions get loud.
Fear, desire, urgency, and hope all start talking at once. In those moments, people often assume the strongest internal voice must be God.
But intensity isn’t the same thing as clarity.
God’s voice is often steady — even when emotions are not.
Why Clarity Often Returns When You Slow Down
One of the simplest but hardest truths about discernment is this:
Clarity usually comes when you stop pushing for it.
When you pause, breathe, and release the pressure to “figure it out,” the internal noise begins to settle. That’s often when God’s guidance becomes noticeable again — not because He suddenly arrived, but because you made room to listen.
Slowing down isn’t avoidance.
It’s discernment hygiene.
A Diagnostic Check (Not a Test)
If you’re trying to figure out whether something is God or just your thoughts, ask yourself:
Am I trying to decide this quickly, or wisely?
Have I already sensed peace — and talked myself out of it?
Am I listening for guidance, or for reassurance?
Would stepping back for a moment make this clearer?
These questions don’t produce instant answers.
They help you identify what’s interfering with discernment.
What Discernment Actually Requires
Discernment isn’t about eliminating your thoughts.
It’s about learning how to separate God’s guidance from emotional static.
That skill develops with practice, not perfection.
When you understand why discernment gets confusing, you stop blaming yourself for the confusion. You stop assuming silence means absence. And you stop treating clarity like something fragile you might break.
You begin to listen with confidence instead of fear.
And that changes how you move forward.
Check out the FREE masterclass!
How to Clarify God’s Unique Blueprint for Your Life is designed to help you make confident, God-led decisions even if you’re not sure how to hear Him yet.